The modern environmental movement, founded on the very best of principles—protecting people and the planet—is failing.
To put it bluntly, many of the policies promoted to address the most serious and high profile environmental problems—climate change, declining biodiversity, oceanic dead zones, and tropical deforestation—simply aren’t working. Worse, some of those policies have become politically divisive and, in more than a few cases, actually make the problems worse.
It’s time to reconsider what we’re doing.
For the sake of this discussion, we can view environmentalism as a kind of social operating system, akin to a computer’s operating system. Like computer operating systems, environmentalism has proceeded through a series of versions, which can be referred to as Env1.0, 2.0, etc. This essay describes and evaluates Env1.0, which was in operation from about 1900 to about 1970, and Env2.0, which has been in operation since 1970. It then lays out a vision for Env3.0.
Env1.0, that of Theodore Roosevelt and Gifford Pinchot (sometimes called conservationism), was grounded in the idea of a human-centered conservation of the environment. Env1.0 was primarily about making sure that humans didn’t over-consume natural resources that humanity might want to use later. The rallying cry of Env1.0 might have been, ‘Save the whales! We will want to eat them later.’ I joke, but this was actually a decent starting point for an environmental operating system because it was scaled to our then-understanding of the environment, both locally and globally. It also reflected what we had the ability to influence in any meaningful way at the time. Unfortunately, it didn’t work well enough and didn’t fulfill our evolving ideas about the environment. The passenger pigeon still went extinct.
Env2.0, founded by people such as Julia Hill, Rachel Carson, Paul Ehrlich, and David Suzuki, and now associated with rituals such as Earth Day, non-governmental organizations such as Greenpeace, Earth First!, and Sierra Club, marked a significant departure from Env1.0.
In Env2.0, nature was seen to have intrinsic value outside of its utility to humanity and lie largely beyond the human power of rational management. Thus, the goal of Env2.0 wasn’t about maintaining and preserving the flow of environmental goods and services feeding human society but sought to wall off the environment from human society as much as possible. The rallying cry of Env2.0 might be caricatured as, ‘The environment is more important than us, we can only bung it up, so leave it alone!’
But Env2.0 is also failing on its own stated terms. Nature is neither being conserved via Env.1.0 nor has it been elevated above human needs and desires or left alone in its perfection via Env2.0.
Read the full piece at Reason